Stay Classy

This is nice.

After rushing into the settlements, Palestinians set fire to empty synagogues in the Morag, Kfar Darom and Netzarim settlements, as well as a Jewish seminary in Neve Dekalim. Later, a Palestinian bulldozer began knocking down the walls of the Netzarim synagogue.

In Netzarim, two young Palestinians waving flags stomped on the smoldering debris outside the synagogue, and others took turns hitting the building with a large hammer.

Bear in mind I have no problem with the PA appropriately demolishing synagogues that the Israeli government left intact after the Gaza pullout.  Gaza is PA-controlled land now, so there needn't be synagogues on that land.  However, the nature of the demolition is what I find upsetting here.  Not a calm, planned, officially controlled demolition of the buildings, but, essentially, a mob rushed in, set fire to the synagogues, and stomped on Israeli flags.

I can understand why this would be emotional for many Palestinians in the area, but this reminds me too much of 11/9/1938 to be comfortable.

Or perhaps I'm being hypersensitive?

UPDATE: Eric Muller expresses similar sentiments.

Continue reading "Stay Classy" »

Real Life Bad@sses

By request over from BTQ, I'd like to talk a little bit about my teacher/guard on my high school experience in Israel.  Summer after my senior year of high school, I went to to Israel for 3 months.  The program I went with was pretty darn cool.  It was designed as a 3 month course on Jewish and Israeli history, but with active learning.  That is, you'd study about an important archaeological site or an important battle, and then you'd actually go to the site itself.  Granted, I was 18 and was even more easily suggestible than I am now, but It was quite powerful and moving.  On multiple occasions, classmates were weeping.

Our madreech or teacher was a man named David.  One of the most interesting people I have ever met, David was also my brother's teacher when he went on the same program a few years earlier than I.  David pretty much looked exactly like Abraham Lincoln, and sported the same kind of beard.  He couldn't have been much more than 5'10", maybe 190-200 lbs.  He was 53 when I was there.  Born and raised in Brooklyn, David still had a thick Brooklyn accent (picture Abe Lincoln sounding like Joe Namath and you get the idea).

He had become very active in Jewish/Israeli nationalism in his youth in the late 50s/early 60s, and had organized some paramilitary groups in the U.S., who, he implied, were involved in smuggling arms into Israel from the U.S.  Eventually, the U.S. go'mment (as it's said in Texas) got annoyed, and basically told David that if he liked Israel so much, he should move there, and not come back.

So he did.  David moved to Israel in the early to mid 1960s, and almost immediately joined Tzahal, the Israeli Army.  He was an infantryman during the Six-Day-War, a member of some of the advance guards that won Jerusalem from Jordanian control (though not one of the first few soldiers into the Old City).

After the war, and though he said he could not talk much about it, he joined Mossad, of which he said that the entrance requirements were the most difficult physical experience of his life (involving, among others, being kidnapped in the middle of the night, beaten up, drugged, thrown onto a plane, and waking up 8 hrs later in an unidentified European country, with no money, no passport or any other ID, and 5-6 Mossad agents trying to catch you before you make it back to Israel).

When we pressed him for details, he would give few, but would press his lips together, and would say only that he had a hand in making sure that some former Nazis disappeared from the light of the world.

I know all this sounds fanciful -- it sounds so to me and I knew the guy -- but if you'd met him, he would have made a believer out of you.

He taught us how to kill someone with a newspaper:

You take the main section, and you fold it in a certain way about fifty times. You end up with a rectangle, probably about 12x6.

The method of folding somehow puts almost all of the paper on each of the four corners, and it becomes really thick; each corner is literally harder than brick. Drive that into someones's forehead, and you'll easily split their skull.

One morning, it was time to climb Masada.  For those who don't know, Masada is one of the enduring symbols of modern Israel.  The slogan of Tzahal is "Masada shall not fall again."

The idea is to be on top to watch the sun rise.  To do so, you've got to take a relatively difficult hike up to the top.  Winding, quite steep in some places, it takes a little over an hour to get to the top.  It was really quite difficult, especially when beginning in the dark at 3:45 in the morning.  Some people were pausing to vomit on the way up.  I hiked next to David the entire time, just chatting, and, after about 20 minutes, I noticed I constant beeping noise coming from David's person.

"What's that noise," I asked.

"My pulse monitor," he replied.

It did not change at all on the entire climb.

On another hike, near the end of the summer, I noticed David wasn't using his right arm to swing himself up, and I asked him if his arm was ok, and he replied that his bicep muscle was torn.  I asked him when he had torn it, and he said he had torn it months prior.  So he was hiking all over the place with basically one arm (he had surgery later).

He carried a Magnum in a hip holster whenever we went on tiyulim, or field trips.  He was not just our teacher; he was also our guard.  He constantly told us that the Hebrews were the knife fighters of the ancient world, and were renowned for centuries for their skill with a blade.  One time, to make some point that I cannot recall the substance of, he brought with him a bunch of knives, and demonstrated his proficiency in throwing them.  Staggering, deadly.

(Sidebar: to this day, Israelis are some of the finest knife fighters in the world.  Filipino culture has been a blade culture for many centuries, and Filipino martial arts are generally regarded as the most advanced and most efficient blade disciplines in the world, but the modern Israelis have really taken some FMA principles, and added and subtracted some of their own techniques to create ITK, Israeli Tactical Knifefighting, which is really the heart of the F.I.G.H.T./Haganah system that I primarily train in.  Master Kanarek, the Chief Instructor of F.I.G.H.T., is one of the world's foremost experts when it comes to modern blade combat).

David had a Master's degree in history from Bar-Ilan University, which has traditionally been regarded as a stronghold for right-wing thinkers and theorists in Israel.  David was both extremely Likud and, like many Israelis, extremely secular.  Interestingly, he had once been extremely religious for some time, but as a student of history and a soldier, he had grown disgusted with the behavior of religious Eastern European Jews in the late 19th, early 20th centurries, let alone the tensions between secular and nonsecular Jews in Israel today.

He observed, correctly, IMO, that had it not been for the secular Zionists in the early 20th century, Israel as a modern political Jewish state would probably not exist today.

Nevertheless, he was undergoing a bit of a spiritual rebirth of his own, and was starting to become observant again by the end of the summer.

The last thing he ever said to me is burned indelibly in my mind.

"[TP], whatever you decide to do with your life, please consider giving yourself to and using your intelligence and your gifts for Israel and the Jewish people.  Both are in desperate need of you."

I will never forget this request.  Never.

Homicide Bombing & Media Distortion

beershevaIn Beer'sheva, the first since March 14. Two buses blew up almost simultaneously. At least 15 people murdered. Horrific.

Rescue workers scoured the scene, cleaning up body parts and scattered pieces of the wreckage as dozens of onlookers gathered nearby. A hand with a ring lay on the ground, and spattered blood covered the walls of the mangled buses.

But look how ridiculous the coverage is from the San Francisco Chronicle:

Palestinian militants haven't carried out a major attack inside Israel since March 14, when 11 people were killed in the port of Ashdod. After that attack, Israel assassinated Sheik Ahmed Yassin, the spiritual leader of Hamas, and his successor, Abdel Aziz Rantisi. Hamas has repeatedly pledged it would avenge their deaths, but had taken little action before Tuesday.

That's grossly misleading. It's not that Hamas has "taken no action." They've taken actions to numerous to count. It's just that that the IDF, fed up with empty PA promises to rein in the terror, is so effing good at what they do, that they have stopped all these actions before they could come to their murderous fruition. Indeed, the article even makes that point.

Israeli forces have arrested or killed dozens of militants in recent months, operating dozens of roadblocks in the West Bank and placing security guards near busy bus stops in Israeli cities.

[. . . ]

Earlier Tuesday, the Israeli army caught a Palestinian man with an explosives belt strapped under his clothing as he tried to cross into Israel from the Gaza Strip. He had waited in line with thousands of Palestinian workers making their way into Israel every morning. Gaza is closed off, and militants have had trouble reaching Israel from there.

In spite of this, the article then slants the evidence by couching in terms of diplomacy, rather than the abundance of cold, hard facts that overwhelmingly point to the conclusion that it is Israel that has stopped Hamas, rather than any lull in Hamas' attempts to murder Israelis:

Israel has said the lull in violence was due to its success in fighting militants, not a lack of effort by armed Palestinian groups.

Israel has said? Yes, Israel has said. But so have veritable mountains of evidence.

Buried in Reuters' version of the same story is this nugget:

Palestinian suicide bombers have killed more than 400 people in Israel since the start of an uprising nearly four years ago. In the same time, Israel has killed more than 3,000 Palestinians in armored raids and air strikes in Gaza and the West Bank.

What, is this supposed to imply equivalence between homicide bombers who intentionally taget civilians, seeking, perhaps hoping to murder women and children, with IDF operations geared at preempting the putative murderers themselves? It is indeed tragic, in a holistic sense, that 3000 Palestinians have died as a result of IDF raids, and of course, not all of these were terrorists.

Nor is Israel relieved of culpability for its actions, and in some cases, its atrocities. But that neither does nor should imply an equivalence between those who intentionally murder women and children, and those who do not. The Reuters article, by placing the numbers of dead side by side, implies a moral equivalence that is grossly misleading, IMO.

So sad.

Olympic Security

I guess it's too late to remind the Iranian Olympic Committee to 'Stay Classy.'

Iranian judoka Arash Mir-Ismaeili, a world champion, announced that he would rather forfeit than square off against Israeli judoka Ehud Vaks at the 2004 Olympics.

However, the decision, apparently, was not his, but was made by the Iranian Olympic Committee:

The Iranian Olympic Committee stated: "It is Iranian policy to avoid competition with athletes from the Zionist entity. Mir-Esmaeili acted according to that policy."

Iran does not recognize Israel's right to exist. In the Middle East, of course, that is not news, as virtually no states other than Egypt and Jordan expressly do recognize Israel's right to exist.

Iranian President Mohammed Khatami rushed to praise Mir-Esmaeili, who carried his country's flag in Friday's opening ceremonies. "We recognize this hero's sacrifice. He will go down in Iranian history with honor and pride." As compensation, Tehran will award him $115,000 that had been set aside had he returned with a gold medal.

[Sidebar: Judo is bad@ss, and IMHO, may well rank as the traditional martial art best suited for RBSD (along with some varieties of Wing Tsun). Though much judo is based on gi techniques, everyone wears clothes on the street, which as anyone practicing submission grappling will tell you, affords opportunity for all manner of chokes. Also, throwing someone down full force on concrete will in all likelihood seriously impinge on their ability to continue an assault encounter. In fact, a former Japanese judo gold medalist, Yoshida Hidehiko, competes in high-level MMA competitions in full gi, and does extremely well.]

It's amazing to me how so many non-Jews wonder why Jews, even in the good 'ol U.S of A, can still feel so threatened. Here is a nation that would rather pay one of its greatest athletes $115,000 than have the athlete compete against a Jew. Musn't touch the unclean Jew.

Perhaps that's unfair; Iran, after all, should be permitted to express its political convictions as it sees fit, no?

I'd be more impressed if the Iranian Olympic Committee actually had the courage to stand by those convictions, however:

[I]n an attempt to evade punishment to athletes who opt out for political considerations, the Iranian delegation chose a different route. Mir-Esmaeili weighed in yesterday morning two kilos over the 66-kg. weight limit in his class.

However, the International Judo Federation (IJF) and Olympic officials understood it was a gimmick. It is unrealistic that an experienced athlete would arrive unprepared for a competition for which he trained for years. Judokas eat a special diet prior to major bouts, arriving within the weight limitation while maximizing their muscle mass.

Mir-Esmaeili hoped his disqualification on a technicality would save him from embarrassing sanctions, but it is unclear, especially after Iranian media declarations emphasized the real reasons were political.

In any case, I'm setting up a straw man: Iran can have whatever political convictions it wishes; that does not mean that I support the positions.

On a related note, I was wondering about the official Grecian policy on security at the games: only Greece's Olympic security forces are allowed to carry weapons.

That may be the policy, but I seriously doubt that's the reality. Consider it from Israel's perspective: when it comes to counter-terrorism, Israeli forces have no parallel, IMO. At the very least, they are among the best in the world, partly because they have dealt with terrorism on a daily basis for so many years.

Given what happened in 1972, if I were Israel, I would essentially laugh in the face of any Grecian official informing me that the best counter-terrorist forces in the world are not permitted to protect Israeli athletes.

Now, this most assuredly is not meant to demean or discredit the abilities of the Grecian Olympic security forces, which, along with training assistance from the U.S., G.B., and Israel, may well be doing a yeoman's job (really, I am even more assuredly not qualified to judge how they are doing). Really, this has nothing to do with the quality of the security in Athens.

I spent much more time discussing Israel on TP v. 1.0 then I do now. Perhaps it's because of my desire to avoid discussing anything remotely political, perhaps it's because others, both in the blogosphere and beyond, cover the subject so well.

But regular readers know that the core of my belief in the necessity of an independent, sovereign Jewish nation is a realpolitik argument that only such a state, able to defend itself and its Jewish citizens (which includes absorbing or otherwise protecting Jewish expatriates in times of severe crisis), offers the best chance of avoiding a new Shoah. As such, the ability of Israelis to protect Israelis, especially when the level of security provided is of such a high quality, is of great importance to me.

Aside from my personal views on the matter, given the context of both Israeli counter-terrorist forces and the specter of the 1972 games, I'd be willing to wager that regardless of what official Grecian policy on the question is, there are indeed armed Israeli security personnel on hand, protecting Israeli athletes. As there ought to be.

Gone

Israel assassinated Sheik Ahmed Yassin. This is a man who has admitted ordering the murders of hundreds of women and children, a man who Israel, in a show of good faith I did not agree with, let free from prison.

It is a sad world when one feels some measure of relief at the death of another human being, but make no mistake about it, this is war.

What am I missing? Why is this controversial?

Go visit a possibly less partisan source on Israel for an excellent example of anti-Israeli bias in the popular media.

TP's Two-Ply Wisdom


  • "I live in a shack. I poop in an outhouse. I eat what I kill." --Chappy the survivalist, from King of the Hill's Y2K Episode

  • "With the philosopher's stone, and the elixir, I give it to ya straight, no chase, and no mixer." --Asheru & Blue Black, Theme Music

  • "Your ideas are interesting to me and I would like to subscribe to your newsletter." --Homer Simpson

  • "Many people would rather die than think; in fact, most do." --Bertrand Russell

Use TP At Your Own Risk


  • All opinions expressed here are solely the opinions of the contributors, and are neither representative of nor endorsed by my employer or by any other legal entity. Nothing said on this site shall be construed as legal advice, or as forming an attorney-client relationship. Persons seeking legal advice should retain counsel.

TP For Your Rods and Cones

October 2005

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
            1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8
9 10 11 12 13 14 15
16 17 18 19 20 21 22
23 24 25 26 27 28 29
30 31          
Blog powered by TypePad